Monticello Investment Analysis
Investment Property in Monticello, NY
Monticello, NY Real Estate Investment Performance
$279,833
Median
1,948
Avg/Sq.ft.
2.00%
Traditional
N/A
Airbnb
39
Investment
62
Airbnb
13
Traditional
20%
Airbnb occupancy rate
Redfin Housing market insights powered by Redfin
7
Number of homes sold
36
Median days on market
98%
Average sale-to-list price ratio
18%
Percentage of listings with price drops
39
Active listings count
29
New listings count
13.2
Months of supply
Monticello, NY Properties Rental Prices
Predict Short-Term Rental Revenue
Want to host your STR property on Airbnb?
Our Airbnb calculator is a free tool to calculate how much can you make on Airbnb.
Investment Properties for Sale in Monticello, NY
$160,000
MLS 994431
Other
CAP RATE
Trad.
1.52%
Airbnb
7.71%
$175,000
MLS 940546
Other
CAP RATE
Trad.
0.52%
Airbnb
6.81%
$179,000
MLS 1026848
Other
CAP RATE
Trad.
1.16%
Airbnb
6.60%
$199,999
MLS 921603
Other
CAP RATE
Trad.
0.07%
Airbnb
5.62%
$64,999
MLS 944437
Manufactured Home
CAP RATE
Trad.
11.05%
Airbnb
5.79%
$105,000
MLS 883967
Manufactured Home
CAP RATE
Trad.
10.94%
Airbnb
5.33%
$200,000
MLS 1014425
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
3.27%
Airbnb
4.81%
$224,900
MLS 854177
Other
CAP RATE
Trad.
-0.24%
Airbnb
4.70%
Single Family Houses for Sale in Monticello, NY
$200,000
MLS 1014425
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
3.27%
Airbnb
4.81%
$229,000
MLS 1049660
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
2.73%
Airbnb
3.86%
$230,000
MLS 1023110
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
2.18%
Airbnb
3.82%
$259,000
MLS 1014071
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
3.83%
Airbnb
3.79%
$280,000
MLS 909073
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
8.16%
Airbnb
3.12%
$260,000
MLS 1042517
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
2.94%
Airbnb
3.07%
$310,000
MLS 1008361
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
7.88%
Airbnb
2.99%
$299,000
MLS 992122
Single Family Residential
CAP RATE
Trad.
5.25%
Airbnb
2.91%
Multi Family Houses for sale in Monticello, NY
$240,000
MLS 1051409
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
7.36%
Airbnb
3.55%
$275,000
MLS 1023405
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
3.58%
Airbnb
3.29%
$275,000
MLS 1023414
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
5.87%
Airbnb
2.76%
$425,000
MLS 1032198
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
-0.51%
Airbnb
1.21%
$349,000
MLS 1008135
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
5.15%
Airbnb
1.06%
$599,900
MLS 984174
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
2.96%
Airbnb
0.68%
$1,099,000
MLS 1032977
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
1.40%
Airbnb
0.05%
$649,900
MLS H6318803
Multi Family
CAP RATE
Trad.
1.18%
Airbnb
-0.51
Top Monticello, NY Neighborhoods - Real Estate Market Analysis
Monticello
$247,500
Median for city
3.52%
Traditional
5.18%
Airbnb
$ 1,397
Traditional
$ 2,253
Airbnb
46%
Airbnb occupancy rate
Popular Blog Posts
The Rental-Ready Checklist: What Homeowners Should Fix, Upgrade, and Calculate Before Renting Out Their Home
Sep 16 2026
, by Ahmad Hashlamoun
Rental Rates API: How to Pull Accurate Rent Estimates for Any US Address
Jul 12 2026
, by Ahmad Hashlamoun
Popular Airbnb Topics
![%=topPerformingBlogs[i].title%>](https://images.mashvisor.com/40X40/C/https://www.mashvisor.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/FIFA-World-Cup-2026-The-Airbnb-Hosts-Playbook-for-the-Decades-Biggest-STR-Opportunity-585x390.jpg)
FIFA World Cup 2026: The Airbnb Host’s Playbook for the Decade’s Biggest STR Opportunity
Jun 2 2026
, by Ahmad Hashlamoun
![%=topPerformingBlogs[i].title%>](https://images.mashvisor.com/40X40/C/https://www.mashvisor.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Airbnb-Just-Changed-How-Guests-Book-585x390.jpg)
Airbnb Just Rewired How Guests Book; What Every Host and PM Needs to Do Right Now
May 22 2026
, by Ahmad Hashlamoun
![%=topPerformingBlogs[i].title%>](https://images.mashvisor.com/40X40/C/https://www.mashvisor.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Copilot_20250901_142238-585x390.png)
How to Survive Airbnb’s 15.5% Single Fee for Hosts and PMS Users with Mashvisor’s Rental Calculator
Sep 1 2025
, by Marina Kolyvanova
Best Short Term Rental Markets
Find great vacation rentals for sale in the top performing markets
Short Term Rentals For SaleAirbnb Vacation Rentals in Monticello, NY
$229 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 33%
Entire cottage 2 · 2 · 4
Rental Income: $2,309 per month
416
$177 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 50%
House 3 · 1 · 6
Rental Income: $2,699 per month
272
$524 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 47%
House 5 · 3 · 15
Rental Income: $7,554 per month
195
$448 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 45%
House 3 · 2.5 · 6
Rental Income: $6,123 per month
186
$84 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 41%
Apartment 2 · 1 · 4
Rental Income: $1,036 per month
183
$205 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 44%
Entire cabin 2 · 1 · 4
Rental Income: $2,750 per month
173
$245 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 45%
Entire cottage 2 · 1 · 4
Rental Income: $3,348 per month
172
$495 per night
Airbnb occupancy rate 40%
House 3 · 2.5 · 12
Rental Income: $5,981 per month
172
Real Estate Investment Analysis - Other Cities in new york
| City Name | Property price | Cash on cash return | Rental Income | No. of Properties | Airbnb Occupancy Rate | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Median | traditional | Airbnb | traditional | Airbnb | |||
| New York | $875,000 | 1% | 1% | $3,125 | $3,462 | 27,153 | 36% |
| Newburgh | $399,000 | 4% | 1% | $2,821 | $1,936 | 426 | 27% |
| Utica | $219,000 | 7% | 3% | $2,028 | $1,472 | 419 | 24% |
| Monroe | $562,000 | 3% | 2% | $3,369 | $3,800 | 160 | 29% |
| Levittown | $759,990 | 3% | 3% | $3,971 | $5,681 | 151 | 26% |
Vacation Rentals for Sale in new york
Your search for investment property begins and ends here