Monticello Investment Analysis

Investment Property in Monticello, NY

Home Investment Performance Rent Prices Top Properties Top Neighborhoods Attractions Insights

Monticello, NY Real Estate Investment Performance

PROPERTY SALE PRICE

$ 375,000

Median

1,973

Avg/Sq.ft.

CASH ON CASH RETURN

4.00%

Traditional

2.00%

Airbnb

RENTAL INCOME

$ 2,675

Traditional

$ 2,124

Airbnb

RENTAL INCOME

$ 2,675

Traditional

$ 2,124

Airbnb

NUMBER OF PROPERTIES

35

Investment

67

Airbnb

32

Traditional

23%

Airbnb occupancy rate

Monticello, NY Properties Rental Prices

RENTAL STRATEGY	1 ROOM	2 ROOMS	3 ROOMS	4 ROOMS
Airbnb	$ 1,694	$ 1,588	$ 2,124	$ 1,908
Traditional	$ 1,092	$ 1,520	$ 1,900	$ 2,470

Airbnb

1 ROOM	$ 1,694
2 ROOMS	$ 1,588
3 ROOMS	$ 2,124
4 ROOMS	$ 1,908

Traditional

1 ROOM	$ 1,092
2 ROOMS	$ 1,520
3 ROOMS	$ 1,900
4 ROOMS	$ 2,470

Predict Short-Term Rental Revenue

Want to host your STR property on Airbnb?
Our Airbnb calculator is a free tool to calculate how much can you make on Airbnb.

Airbnb Calculator

Investment Properties for Sale in Monticello, NY

$332,499

MLS 907647

10 Varnell Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

5 beds 2 baths 2,034 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. N/A Airbnb 6.49%

Analyze Property

$215,000

MLS 900533

3560 State Route 42, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 2 baths 1,514 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 8.84% Airbnb 4.86%

Analyze Property

$249,999

MLS 897054

6 Leonardo Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 1 baths 1,027 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 5.77% Airbnb 4.45%

Analyze Property

$479,999

MLS 897924

39 Dingle Daisy Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

5 beds 2 baths 2,062 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 3.97% Airbnb 4.27%

Analyze Property

$274,999

MLS 891553

253 Harris Bushville Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 2 baths 1,540 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 6.46% Airbnb 3.75%

Analyze Property

$299,000

MLS 891982

123 Robert Lane, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 2 baths 1,222 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 5.84% Airbnb 3.31%

Analyze Property

$319,900

MLS 912957

194 Old Liberty Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 1 baths 1,508 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 3.88% Airbnb 2.81%

Analyze Property

$299,000

MLS 877940

62 Clinton Avenue, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Multi Family

7 beds 3 baths 1,568 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 7.17% Airbnb 2.51%

Analyze Property

Single Family Houses for Sale in Monticello, NY

$332,499

MLS 907647

10 Varnell Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

5 beds 2 baths 2,034 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. N/A Airbnb 6.49%

Analyze Property

$215,000

MLS 900533

3560 State Route 42, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 2 baths 1,514 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 8.84% Airbnb 4.86%

Analyze Property

$249,999

MLS 897054

6 Leonardo Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 1 baths 1,027 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 5.77% Airbnb 4.45%

Analyze Property

$479,999

MLS 897924

39 Dingle Daisy Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

5 beds 2 baths 2,062 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 3.97% Airbnb 4.27%

Analyze Property

$274,999

MLS 891553

253 Harris Bushville Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 2 baths 1,540 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 6.46% Airbnb 3.75%

Analyze Property

$299,000

MLS 891982

123 Robert Lane, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 2 baths 1,222 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 5.84% Airbnb 3.31%

Analyze Property

$319,900

MLS 912957

194 Old Liberty Road, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 1 baths 1,508 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 3.88% Airbnb 2.81%

Analyze Property

$449,900

MLS 862425

3342 State Route 42, Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello

Single Family Residential

3 beds 3 baths 1,918 sq.ft.

CAP RATE Trad. 5.95% Airbnb 2.24%

Analyze Property

Top Monticello, NY Neighborhoods - Real Estate Market Analysis

Monticello

53%

53% Mashmeter

PROPERTY PRICE

$247,500

Median for city

CAP RATE

3.52%

Traditional

5.18%

Airbnb

RENTAL INCOME

$ 1,397

Traditional

$ 2,253

Airbnb

46%

Airbnb occupancy rate

Analyze neighborhood

Best Short Term Rental Markets

Find great vacation rentals for sale in the top performing markets

Short Term Rentals For Sale

Airbnb Vacation Rentals in Monticello, NY

$209 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 36%

Entire cottage 2 · 2 · 4

Modern Upstate Escape with Outdoor Sauna Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $2,299 per month

4.94

377

$188 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 42%

House 3 · 1 · 6

Dancing Feather: Cozy Lake-Front A-Frame Chalet Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $2,381 per month

4.91

236

$77 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 29%

Apartment 2 · 1 · 4

Catskill Cozy Shack in Village of Monticello Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $687 per month

4.56

178

$485 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 36%

House 5 · 3 · 15

Magical Lake House-Hot Tub-Deck-Outdoor Kitchen Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $5,254 per month

4.95

172

$287 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 15%

House 3 · 2.5 · 6

Secluded lakefront home With an EV charger Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $1,292 per month

4.97

148

$208 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 27%

Entire cabin 2 · 1 · 4

Cozy Catskills Cabin Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $1,699 per month

4.94

146

$443 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 21%

House 3 · 2.5 · 13

Catskills Lakefront Haven w/ Hot Tub & Game Room Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $2,843 per month

4.93

145

$196 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 21%

Entire cabin 2 · 1 · 6

Blue House | Cedar tub•BBQ•fire pit•stargazing Monticello, New York, United States

Rental Income: $1,225 per month

4.92

140

Real Estate Investment Analysis - Other Cities in new york

City Name	Property price	Cash on cash return		Rental Income		No. of Properties	Airbnb Occupancy Rate
City Name	Median	traditional	Airbnb	traditional	Airbnb	No. of Properties	Airbnb Occupancy Rate
New York	$799,000	2%	2%	$3,225	$3,543	5,618	32%
Utica	$199,900	9%	4%	$2,289	$2,369	126	29%
Newburgh	$425,000	4%	1%	$3,195	$2,286	107	33%
Levittown	$734,500	3%	3%	$4,024	$5,681	106	28%
Lindenhurst	$619,990	4%	2%	$3,885	$2,642	105	38%
Hempstead	$675,000	3%	1%	$3,922	$3,435	75	33%
Commack	$850,000	3%	2%	$4,744	$5,428	64	37%
Deer Park	$665,000	4%	2%	$4,021	$5,060	57	32%