Real Estate Investment Properties for Sale in Cincinnatus, NY

Looking for investment property in Cincinnatus, NY with high ROI ?

Explore a variety of short-term homes & houses in Cincinnatus, NY. Invest wisely with VRBO & Cincinnatus, NY Airbnb properties available for purchase. Find your ideal investment property among our curated listings for a rewarding real estate venture.

Investment Property for Sale in Cincinnatus, NY

separator

PROPERTY	DETAILS	SALE PRICE	INVESTMENT PERFORMANCE
3294 Haines Rd Cincinnatus, NY The epitome of privacy and serenity on this one of a kind 180 acre property. Pull off a qu...	6 beds \| 3 baths \| 2,300 sq.ft.	$425,000	Airbnb cash on cash: N/A Traditional cash on cash: 4.34% Airbnb Rental Income: $null Traditional Rental Income: $3423 Airbnb ROI: N/A Traditional ROI: 4.34%
4555 Elwood Road Cincinnatus, NY Step into a rare and extraordinary retreat where history, design, and nature come together...	4 beds \| 4 baths \| 2,872 sq.ft.	$439,900	Airbnb cash on cash: 8.32% Traditional cash on cash: 4.85% Airbnb Rental Income: $5650 Traditional Rental Income: $3087 Airbnb ROI: 8.32% Traditional ROI: 4.85%
4296 Stramba Rd Cincinnatus, NY 4296 Stramba Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 \| Other	N/A beds \| N/A baths \| N/A	$84,900	Airbnb cash on cash: 0.14% Traditional cash on cash: 1.76% Airbnb Rental Income: $618 Traditional Rental Income: $461 Airbnb ROI: 0.14% Traditional ROI: 1.76%
Stone Rd Cincinnatus, NY Stone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 \| Other	N/A beds \| N/A baths \| N/A	$140,000	Airbnb cash on cash: -0.95% Traditional cash on cash: 0.06% Airbnb Rental Income: $618 Traditional Rental Income: $461 Airbnb ROI: -0.95% Traditional ROI: 0.06%
1981 Carter Slocum Road Cincinnatus, NY Don't miss this fantastic opportunity to own a newly constructed 2025 home offering over 4...	1 beds \| N/A baths \| 4,020 sq.ft.	$299,900	Airbnb cash on cash: 2.48% Traditional cash on cash: 1.21% Airbnb Rental Income: $2236 Traditional Rental Income: $1314 Airbnb ROI: 2.48% Traditional ROI: 1.21%
5763 Telephone Rd Extenstion Ext Cincinnatus, NY 5763 Telephone Rd Extenstion Ext, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 \| Condo/Coop	15 beds \| 6 baths \| 9,416 sq.ft.	$450,000	Airbnb cash on cash: N/A Traditional cash on cash: 8.89% Airbnb Rental Income: $null Traditional Rental Income: $4978 Airbnb ROI: N/A Traditional ROI: 8.89%
2769 Lower Cincinnatus Rd Cincinnatus, NY 2769 Lower Cincinnatus Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 \| Single Family Residential	6 beds \| 2 baths \| 2,324 sq.ft.	$174,900	Airbnb cash on cash: N/A Traditional cash on cash: 9.75% Airbnb Rental Income: $null Traditional Rental Income: $2166 Airbnb ROI: N/A Traditional ROI: 9.75%
149 Hemlock Lane Cincinnatus, NY Welcome to Hemlock Haven Cabin! Beautifully finished chalet-style cabin tucked away in pri...	2 beds \| 1 baths \| 660 sq.ft.	$249,900	Airbnb cash on cash: 8.5% Traditional cash on cash: 5.06% Airbnb Rental Income: $3272 Traditional Rental Income: $1727 Airbnb ROI: 8.5% Traditional ROI: 5.06%

Real Estate investment in Cincinnatus, NY

There are 8 properties for sale in the city of Cincinnatus . The median list price in Cincinnatus is $177,400 and the average price per square foot is $66. In May 2026, the average monthly cash on cash return in Cincinnatus is 5.00%. The average monthly rental income in Cincinnatus is $1,707.

Cincinnatus, NY Real Estate Investing: FAQs for Buyers, Sellers and Investors

There are 8 investment properties available for sale in Cincinnatus.

In 2026, the best neighborhood to buy investment property is Cincinnatus.

The ROI for Short-Term is higher than the Long-Term in Cincinnatus with average rental income of $2,754.

Your search for investment property begins and ends here

Investment Property for Sale in Cincinnatus, NY

3294 Haines Rd

Cincinnatus, NY

6 beds | 3 baths | 2,300 sq.ft.

$425,000

Airbnb cash on cash: N/A

Traditional cash on cash: 4.34%

Airbnb Rental Income: $null

Traditional Rental Income: $3423

Airbnb ROI: N/A

Traditional ROI: 4.34%

4555 Elwood Road

Cincinnatus, NY

4 beds | 4 baths | 2,872 sq.ft.

$439,900

Airbnb cash on cash: 8.32%

Traditional cash on cash: 4.85%

Airbnb Rental Income: $5650

Traditional Rental Income: $3087

Airbnb ROI: 8.32%

Traditional ROI: 4.85%

4296 Stramba Rd

Cincinnatus, NY

N/A beds | N/A baths | N/A

$84,900

Airbnb cash on cash: 0.14%

Traditional cash on cash: 1.76%

Airbnb Rental Income: $618

Traditional Rental Income: $461

Airbnb ROI: 0.14%

Traditional ROI: 1.76%

Stone Rd

Cincinnatus, NY

N/A beds | N/A baths | N/A

$140,000

Airbnb cash on cash: -0.95%

Traditional cash on cash: 0.06%

Airbnb Rental Income: $618

Traditional Rental Income: $461

Airbnb ROI: -0.95%

Traditional ROI: 0.06%

1981 Carter Slocum Road

Cincinnatus, NY

1 beds | N/A baths | 4,020 sq.ft.

$299,900

Airbnb cash on cash: 2.48%

Traditional cash on cash: 1.21%

Airbnb Rental Income: $2236

Traditional Rental Income: $1314

Airbnb ROI: 2.48%

Traditional ROI: 1.21%

5763 Telephone Rd Extenstion Ext

Cincinnatus, NY

15 beds | 6 baths | 9,416 sq.ft.

$450,000

Airbnb cash on cash: N/A

Traditional cash on cash: 8.89%

Airbnb Rental Income: $null

Traditional Rental Income: $4978

Airbnb ROI: N/A

Traditional ROI: 8.89%

2769 Lower Cincinnatus Rd

Cincinnatus, NY

6 beds | 2 baths | 2,324 sq.ft.

$174,900

Airbnb cash on cash: N/A

Traditional cash on cash: 9.75%

Airbnb Rental Income: $null

Traditional Rental Income: $2166

Airbnb ROI: N/A

Traditional ROI: 9.75%

149 Hemlock Lane

Cincinnatus, NY

2 beds | 1 baths | 660 sq.ft.

$249,900

Airbnb cash on cash: 8.5%

Traditional cash on cash: 5.06%

Airbnb Rental Income: $3272

Traditional Rental Income: $1727

Airbnb ROI: 8.5%