Real Estate Investment Properties for Sale in Shelter Island, NY
Looking for investment property in Shelter Island, NY with high ROI ?
Explore a variety of short-term homes & houses in Shelter Island, NY. Invest wisely with VRBO & Shelter Island, NY Airbnb properties available for purchase. Find your ideal investment property among our curated listings for a rewarding real estate venture.
Investment Property for Sale in Shelter Island, NY
| PROPERTY | DETAILS | SALE PRICE | INVESTMENT PERFORMANCE |
|---|---|---|---|
13 Tarkettle RdShelter Island, NYLocation, location, location! This home sits on just over 1 acre of land with over 100 Fee... |
3 beds | 2 baths | 1,373 sq.ft. |
$2,999,000 |
Airbnb cash on cash: -0.48%
|
4 Duvall PlaceShelter Island, NYAmazing 1800s house with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. Perfectly quiet location in Shelter Islan... |
3 beds | 2 baths | 1,200 sq.ft. |
$1,350,000 |
Airbnb cash on cash: -1.19%
|
47B S Ferry RoadShelter Island, NYDiscover a secluded paradise on Shelter Island, nestled within the expansive 2,350-acre Ma... |
3 beds | 2 baths | 1,800 sq.ft. |
$3,995,000 |
Airbnb cash on cash: -0.76%
|
8 Cove WayShelter Island, NYEnviably located on Shelter Island's southern coast with 113' of waterfront on Menantic Cr... |
4 beds | 5 baths | 3,676 sq.ft. |
$4,250,000 |
Airbnb cash on cash: -1.24%
|
10 Sunshine Road #BShelter Island, NYQuintessential Hamptons estate in the heart of Shelter Island . Enjoy the best of both wor... |
4 beds | 5 baths | 5,300 sq.ft. |
$2,795,000 |
Airbnb cash on cash: -1.15%
|
1 Gazon RoadShelter Island, NYThis enchanting Shelter Island home feels like a true getaway. Tucked into a peaceful sett... |
4 beds | 3 baths | 2,618 sq.ft. |
$1,250,000 |
Airbnb cash on cash: -1.14%
|
15A / 15 & 13 S Menantic RdShelter Island, NY15A / 15 & 13 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964 | Single Family Residential |
9 beds | 4 baths | 3,944 sq.ft. |
$9,955,000 |
Airbnb cash on cash: -2.58%
|
Real Estate investment in Shelter-island, NY
There are 14 properties for sale in the city of Shelter Island . The median list price in Shelter Island is $2,499,500 and the average price per square foot is $1,117. In February 2026, the average monthly cash on cash return in Shelter Island is 1.00%. The average monthly rental income in Shelter Island is $5,702.