Oyster Bay Investment Analysis

Investment Property in Oyster Bay, NY

Oyster Bay, NY Real Estate Investment Performance

PROPERTY SALE PRICE

$ 913,500

Median

2,981

Avg/Sq.ft.
CASH ON CASH RETURN

2.00%

Traditional

2.00%

Airbnb
NUMBER OF PROPERTIES

18

Investment

34

Airbnb

61

Traditional

56%

Airbnb occupancy rate

Oyster Bay, NY Properties Rental Prices

Predict Short-Term Rental Revenue

Want to host your STR property on Airbnb?
Our Airbnb calculator is a free tool to calculate how much can you make on Airbnb.

Airbnb Calculator

Investment Properties for Sale in Oyster Bay, NY

Investment Properties for Sale
$490,000
MLS 3514654
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
3 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 6.22% Airbnb 5.67%
Investment Properties for Sale
$798,000
MLS 3531033
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.10% Airbnb 2.63%
Investment Properties for Sale
$839,000
MLS 3525649
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 2 baths 1,600 sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.14% Airbnb 2.31%
Investment Properties for Sale
$825,000
MLS 3524710
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 2.76% Airbnb 2.00%
Investment Properties for Sale
$929,000
MLS 3535856
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
3 beds 3 baths 1,881 sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.22% Airbnb 1.93%
Investment Properties for Sale
$898,000
MLS 3511878
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 3 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 2.80% Airbnb 1.89%
Investment Properties for Sale
$579,000
MLS 3524529
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
2 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.26% Airbnb 1.71%
Investment Properties for Sale
$1,200,000
MLS 3517493
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 3 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 2.11% Airbnb 0.80%

Single Family Houses for Sale in Oyster Bay, NY

Investment Properties for Sale
$490,000
MLS 3514654
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
3 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 6.22% Airbnb 5.67%
Investment Properties for Sale
$798,000
MLS 3531033
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.10% Airbnb 2.63%
Investment Properties for Sale
$839,000
MLS 3525649
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 2 baths 1,600 sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.14% Airbnb 2.31%
Investment Properties for Sale
$825,000
MLS 3524710
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 2.76% Airbnb 2.00%
Investment Properties for Sale
$929,000
MLS 3535856
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
3 beds 3 baths 1,881 sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.22% Airbnb 1.93%
Investment Properties for Sale
$898,000
MLS 3511878
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 3 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 2.80% Airbnb 1.89%
Investment Properties for Sale
$579,000
MLS 3524529
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
2 beds 2 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 3.26% Airbnb 1.71%
Investment Properties for Sale
$1,200,000
MLS 3517493
Oyster Bay
Single Family Residential
4 beds 3 baths N/A sq.ft.
CAP RATE Trad. 2.11% Airbnb 0.80%

Top Oyster Bay, NY Neighborhoods - Real Estate Market Analysis

Oyster Bay
PROPERTY PRICE

$1,084,500

Median for city
CAP RATE

1.10%

Traditional

0.62%

Airbnb
RENTAL INCOME

$ 2,555

Traditional

$ 3,159

Airbnb

50%

Airbnb occupancy rate

Popular Blog Posts

Popular Airbnb Topics

Looking for
Airbnb Analytics?

Gain vacation rental insights of any US market with our Airbnb data analytics

Best Short Term Rental Markets

Find great vacation rentals for sale in the top performing markets

Short Term Rentals For Sale

Airbnb Vacation Rentals in Oyster Bay, NY

Comfy studio in Bethpage
$84 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 82%
Apartment 1 · 1 · 2
Rental Income: $2,107 per month
5
209
Newly Renovated Private Studio on Long Island
$103 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 91%
Guest suite 0 · 1 · 3
Rental Income: $2,858 per month
5
134
Welcome Home-Stress Free Zone-
$120 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 95%
House 2 · 1 · 5
Rental Income: $3,480 per month
5
131
Entire house in Hicksville
$137 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 93%
House 2 · 2 · 4
Rental Income: $3,882 per month
5
114
3bd luxury duplex condo Westbury
$220 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 78%
Condominium 3 · 2 · 6
Rental Income: $5,207 per month
5
96
2bd luxury condoWestbury
$163 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 77%
Condominium 2 · 1 · 4
Rental Income: $3,803 per month
5
55
Newly Renovated Personal Apartment in Long Island
$134 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 66%
House 1 · 1 · 4
Rental Income: $2,714 per month
5
51
Cozy 1 Bedroom Apt. W Private Entrance
$102 per night Airbnb occupancy rate 72%
House 1 · 1 · 2
Rental Income: $2,236 per month
5
50

Real Estate Investment Analysis - Other Cities in new-york

City Name Property price Cash on cash return Rental Income No. of Properties Airbnb Occupancy Rate
Median traditional Airbnb traditional Airbnb
Yonkers $295,000 3% 4% $2,681 $2,918 286 73%
Lindenhurst $599,000 4% 4% $3,928 $4,313 79 67%
Commack $749,000 3% 4% $4,671 $5,428 47 67%
Hempstead $589,999 4% 4% $4,203 $4,501 87 67%
New York $756,000 2% 1% $3,305 $3,217 8,945 67%
Baldwin $629,000 4% 2% $4,417 $3,806 65 65%
Deer Park $587,000 4% 3% $4,100 $4,142 54 65%
Ossining $560,000 3% 2% $3,589 $3,328 48 64%
Locust Valley $1,145,000 2% 9% $5,156 $12,938 13 63%
Plainview $949,000 2% 1% $4,647 $4,278 71 62%
Westbury $710,000 3% 3% $4,002 $4,570 67 61%
Levittown $649,450 4% 6% $4,307 $7,187 72 61%
Newburgh $399,950 5% 5% $2,846 $3,888 94 60%
Uniondale $587,000 5% 5% $3,813 $5,753 18 58%
Marlboro $515,000 4% 2% $3,427 $3,379 15 52%
Monroe $475,000 4% 7% $3,082 $4,697 28 49%
Islip $549,500 3% 3% $3,943 $4,649 34 49%
Utica $159,000 9% 10% $1,814 $2,524 105 47%
Mastic $459,000 6% 9% $3,795 $5,266 42 45%
Calverton $314,999 8% 12% $4,129 $5,431 13 38%
View all new-york cities

Vacation Rentals for Sale in new-york

Your search for investment property begins and ends here

Use analytics to find lucrative traditional or Airbnb properties in a matter of minutes.

No more spreadsheets, no more searching.